Skip to main content

Brexit and the EU Act 2011

The Mirror 10th March draws attention to a plans by "Best for Britain" to bring judicial review proceedings in an attempt to require the government to hold a further referendum on Brexit.  According to the Mirror - " ... judges will be asked to ­judicially review whether Mr Davis’s Brexit negotiations are unconstitutional."  Their basis for this appears to be the referendum requirements in the European Union Act 2011 which apply to new treaties amending or replacing either the Treaty on European Union or the Treaty on the Functioning of the EU.  (See also The Independent 11th March).

An inconvenient point
for Best for Britain is that  the European Union (Withdrawal) Bill contains provisions to repeal the European Union Act 2011.  First, there is Clause 17.  Secondly, there is Schedule 9.  Those must be considered in the light of Clause 19.  All of this is rather dull, legalistic, material but here goes:

Clause 17 is headed "Consequential and Transitional Provision" and Clause 17(7) gives effect to Schedule 9 which will repeal various Acts including the European Union Act 2011.  Clause 19 deals with Commencement.  Only certain sections will come into force on the day the Act is passed - see 19(1).  Clause 19(2) states - "The remaining provisions of this Act come into force on such day as a Minister of the Crown may by regulations appoint; and different days may be appointed for different purposes."

So, once the Bill receives Royal Assent, the Minister can make a regulation - by way of Clause 19(2) - bringing Schedule 9 at least partially into force so that any part of the 2011 Act requiring a referendum no longer applies.

The Withdrawal Bill is now undergoing its committee stage in the House of Lords and it is open to them to amend the Bill so as to protect the 2011 Act.  Whether this will happen remains to be seen.

As things stand, the 2011 Act "referendum lock" need not be an obstacle to a government determined to secure Brexit. 

My view on this almost a year ago is HERE. 

Discussion re the 2011 Act - UK Constitutional Law Group blog 


Another challenge:

A further challenge by "Crowdjustice" is currently before the High Court - see HERE.  This challenge argues that Parliament has never delegated the withdrawal decision to the people and has never made the withdrawal decision itself.  Consequently, the Article 50 notification is predicated on a decision that has no basis in law.  Judicial review has to be brought within strict time limits and the court's permission is required.  In February, on the basis of the papers filed, the court refused permission but there is to be an oral permission hearing.

Some points / thoughts:

The European Union (Referendum) Act 2015 - Parliament could have made it clear in the Act that the referendum outcome was to be legally binding.  It did not do so. 

Article 50(1) TEU- "Any Member State may decide to withdraw from the Union in accordance with its own constitutional requirements."  What those requirements are is a matter for domestic law and not EU law.

The UK's unwritten / informal constitutional arrangements do not dictate any specific way by which important decisions are to be made.  In practice, the government of the day determines its policy and will then seek any necessary legislation to give effect to that policy.  Whilst Article 50 refers to a "decision" it is essential to recognise that Brexit can be achieved via this usual process.  Following the 2016 referendum, the government determined that Brexit had to be implemented and it will be implemented provided they can secure the necessary legislation.  Parliament is in the process of doing this - e.g. the European Union (Withdrawal) Bill. 


For those seeking some form of "decision" it is possible to glean a form of decision from events - the referendum result,  the subsequent debates in Parliament demonstrating political acceptance of the referendum (e.g. debate 27th June 2016,  resolution of 12th October 2016 and the Motion of the House of Commons of 7 December 2016*) and the enactment of the European Union (Notification of Withdrawal) Act 2017.

Parliament - as the UK's sovereign body - could make a formal decision to leave the EU and could expressly state that decision in legislation but it would appear that it is not necessary for it to do so. 

* 7th December 2016
That this House recognises that leaving the EU is the defining issue facing the UK; notes the resolution on parliamentary scrutiny of the UK leaving the EU agreed by the House on 12 October 2016; recognises that it is Parliament’s responsibility to properly scrutinise the Government while respecting the decision of the British people to leave the European Union; … recognises that this House should respect the wishes of the United Kingdom as expressed in the referendum on 23 June; and further calls on the Government to invoke Article 50 by 31 March 2017.
This motion was passed by 448 votes to 75. 

Law and Lawyers 16th June 2017 - The (elusive) decision to leave the EU


Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The Fastest Way To Lose Weight For Women

Have you been looking for the fastest way to shed pounds for girls however have come up empty handed? Is there a reason why girls have exclusive questions and issues than guys with regard to health? There is a lot incorrect information and contradictions in the health enterprise that it is able to make your head spin. We are going to address the ones very problems and get proper to the point. You want to lose weight the healthy way and also you want it fast. Let's jump proper in! 1)Fasting 1-2 times every week Don't fear approximately "ravenous" yourself or wondering if your frame will cross into "hunger mode." This is one in all the biggest myths of the diet and health industry. Fasting for a 24 hour period 1-2 instances per week is a completely healthful and useful way to lose fats. Fasting offers the digestive machine a break whilst creating a big caloric deficit this is needed to lose the extra pounds. Fasting has also been related to assuaging health tr...
Post a Comment
Read more

How Do You Get Lean? Start Eating Functionally

 Now, I like most of the people enjoy a chunk of ingesting out, specially breakfasts and even takeaways now and then and these ingredients can be included into your upkeep diet in moderation depending to your interest degree and fitness situation, however on the subject of achieving your goal within the first area a disciplined strategy is required. The manner to consume to get lean is knowing the GI/GL cost of the ingredients you eat and the way those impact the glycogen stores in your muscle groups and liver, to get lean you want to lower those shops so that you can enter the fat burning sector. So going into this you want to have your desires clean, you are trying to lose body fat, you want to be leaner and it's going to take discipline and effort, human beings that strive to tell you in any other case are possibly looking to kid you into shopping for their merchandise or some thing on the premise that it's the clean way. Now it's handiest human nature to are seeking ...
Post a Comment
Read more

Tips For Women Trying to Lose Body Fat

  Most dieters understand the physical venture of seeking to shed pounds, however many dieters forget the psychological struggles ahead. Below are  guidelines for women trying to lose body fat. Don't Live By The Scale When beginning a new diet you need to put yourself for fulfillment, no longer failure. One way to improve your motivation and keep losing body fats is to area less emphasis on a weight scale. It's not unusual for dieters who've exercised continuously and feel great to lose motivation when they step on a scale. Losing frame fat, and dropping body weight are not the same aim. It's possible to lessen your body fat and advantage new muscle without dropping a unmarried pound of frame weight, due to the fact the moves offset one another. A fantastic action may be perceived as negative when that happens. You have much less body fat with greater muscle definition, however you view the development in a bad light due to the fact your frame weight is the same....
Post a Comment
Read more